Saturday interview with Phil Burton Cartledge at All That Is Solid …: Anna Chen
Extracts: highlights and lowlifes
– Why did you start blogging?
I started blogging as Madam Miaow in 2007 to stop me chucking heavy objects through the television screen. I needed not only to vent, but to order my thoughts when faced with the all-pervading mess out there. I’m sure there are many of us who have been kept sane by having the option to communicate our views to an audience, even a small one. It’s a healthy way to make sense of an increasingly chaotic world.
– What set of ideas do you think it most important to disseminate?
A rising tide floats all boats. Rosa Luxemburg’s warning that the choice would be between socialism or barbarism grows truer by the minute. Socialism is supposed to about an egalitarian, freeing society; from each according to their ability, to each according to their need, not a wholesale troughing down by power-hungry opportunists.
– What set of ideas do you think it most important to combat?
Nationalism, anti-immigration, racism, sexism. I would include reformism if only there was a socialist alternative.
– How about political villains?
Anyone who rises through the left only to take an axe to the movement as soon as they see an opportunity to climb the greasy pole — they have done so much damage to the movement and proper socialism which should represent liberation for the majority. The SWP analysis in the late 1990s predicted that Blair would be right-wing and betray the working class who would move rightwards so it was vital that we build an alternative to Labour. They were correct in that instance yet here we are over a decade later with the left worse than ever following pointless sectarian punch-ups mostly initiated by the SWP when a strong principled left has never been more desperately needed.
– What do you consider to be the main threat to the future peace and security of the world?
The constant upward suck of wealth with our resources accreting in the hands of a tiny global elite. This can’t carry on without major crises and a battle to redistribute fairly. Trouble is, they now have the technology to hang on to their ill-gotten gains and leave us behind. Recent “revolutions” have not been inspiring, they’ve simply meant a change of personnel at the top as die alte scheisse takes over.
– What would be your most important piece of advice about life?
Beware inadequates — they loathe you. Learn to tell the difference between lip-service and action. If love isn’t part of your politics, then you have no business telling others what to do and how to run the world. Far from being romantic nonsense as so many cynics would have it, love is the highest plane on which human beings as social animals interact. We need to develop 360 degree abilities and wider bandwidth.
– What do you consider the most important personal quality?
Capacity for love — not the romantic kind, the other bigger one that encompasses generosity, solidarity and comradeship. Intelligence versus cleverness.
– And any pet peeves?
Mockney accents on posh leftists who tell working-class people how to be working-class. Purported progressives and anti-racists I’ve never met projecting their yellow peril fears onto me. Leftists who fall over themselves to appropriate your labour and the comrades who turn a blind eye. The snowy blinding WHITENESS of the left groups and the obvious lack of diversity, often manifesting as outright hostility towards Other. Organisations that bolt themselves to the front of other people’s struggle and then claim leadership rights. None of this helps us advance our political cause.
– What piece of advice would you give to your much younger self?
Use softening rose water instead of tonics that strip your skin and dry it up. Don’t smoke or stay in the sun too long.
Don’t go anywhere near the British far left. Too many charlatans, careerists and snake-oil salesmen and women with ambitions who are happy to plant their boot in your face if it means personal advancement as soon as something’s up for grabs. Suddenly, gay rights are no longer a “shibboleth”, that rape never happened and “what’s yours is mine”. Wise up to the fact that, just because someone says the right thing, it doesn’t mean they live it. No-one on the left has your back if you are already a marginalised minority because so many of them are insecure, chasing status, career, youth and power, and they harbour a deep contempt for those who they see as occupying the bottom of society, whatever lip-service they pay otherwise — it’s their own self-loathing projected out. Just because you are comradely, principled and non-sectarian, it doesn’t mean everyone else is, too, simply because they’ve read the right books. Watch out for the middle-class ones who sneer at ethics and morality as “bourgeois”, forgetting that Trotsky wrote a book called Their Morals and Ours, not Their Morals and We Ain’t Got None.
Anna’s food blog here:
http://annacheneats.blogspot.com/